Welcome to Lucy's New York Style Pizza
Lucy's New York Style Pizza, located at 210 2nd Ave S in Twin Falls, ID, offers a genuine taste of New York with its signature pizzas and calzones. Customers rave about the impressive flavor and authenticity, especially the Meaty calzone and unique pickle pizza. With a commitment to quality, Lucy's pairs chewy crusts with tangy sauce and gooey cheese, replicating the beloved NYC style. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff enhance the dining experience, making it a favorite among locals. Whether you’re enjoying a classic slice or a creative specialty, Lucy’s invites you to indulge in a true pizza delight.
-
210 2nd Ave S, Twin Falls, ID 83301, United States210 2nd Ave S, Twin Falls, ID 83301, United States Hotline: +1 208-933-2000
Welcome to Lucy's New York Style Pizza, a slice of New York nestled in the heart of Twin Falls, Idaho. Located at 210 2nd Ave S, this pizzeria captures the essence of authentic New York-style pizza, serving up a delightful range of flavors that will transport you straight to the bustling streets of NYC with every bite. You can reach them at +1 208-933-2000.
Lucy's menu features an impressive lineup of 12-inch pizzas that cater to every palate. The Margherita, priced at just US$15.50, is a refreshing take on the classic with vibrant fresh tomatoes and fragrant basil. For spice enthusiasts, the Buffalo pizza, loaded with house-made chicken and warm buffalo sauce, is a must-try at US$14.50. Vegetarians will rejoice over the Veggie pizza—topped with an enticing medley of vegetables—including artichokes, peppers, and mushrooms, available for US$18.00. And for meat lovers, the Meaty option, featuring a hearty combination of pepperoni, ham, sausage, and meatballs, promises satisfaction and bold flavors.
But it’s not just the pizzas that shine here. Lucy’s also offers mouthwatering appetizers like their Fried Mutz—delicious whole milk cheese hand-breaded and fried, perfect for sharing at US$5.00. Don’t miss out on the cheesy bliss of their Cheesesticks, complementing the breadsticks with melted mozzarella for just US$6.00. And if you're feeling adventurous, give their unique pickle pizza a shot. Though customer opinions vary on the thickness of the pickles, the flavor consistently hits the mark.
Customer reviews echo the warmth and welcoming atmosphere that Lucy's embodies. Cheyenne Johannsen raved about the speedy and kind service, adding a personal touch to her dining experience. Meanwhile, Garrett Rice found the food delightful, even if slightly oily, praising the staff's friendliest. Mark P, a true New Yorker, was taken back by the quality of pizza in Idaho, labeling Lucy’s offering as genuinely impressive. Carol Weber also sang praises for the chewy crust, tangy sauce, and delectable meatball subs, making Lucy's her go-to spot.
Lucy's New York Style Pizza promises more than just a meal; it offers a culinary experience that captures the spirit of New York. So, whether you’re craving a slice or looking for a perfect spot for a casual meal, Lucy's is ready to serve you hearty flavors, delectable crusts, and an atmosphere infused with the welcoming charm of friendly service. Come hungry, leave satisfied!
The girl with pink hair was amazing! Service was so fast and she was so sweet! I didn't get to catch her name but i definitely recommend coming here!!
Due recent reviews I was kinda iffy on coming here. Thought i’d give it a chance, and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza tasted amazing but was a little oily. Also very surprised with how friendly and welcoming the staff were. Overall if you’re wondering if you should come here, my advice is to give it a go!
I finally tried their pickle pizza. It was delicious!! The pickles were a little thick in my opinion but that is just a personal texture thing. Regardless the flavor was on point.
I grew up in NY so I know good pizza. Moving to Idaho, I wasn't expecting much out of the pizza here. Surprisingly, Lucy's is very good. I was honestly shocked. Great pizza, definitely give the Pizzle with grilled chicken a try. The Meaty is also a favorite.
Outstanding service, pizza & meatball subs. Cool atmosphere too. Very, very close to NY style. Chewy crust, tangy sauce, stringy cheese. Meatballs are on point. Our go-to in Twin Falls.
We love Lucy pizza! The fresh veggies are a game changer with the best crust that’s thats thin and delicious! We order here on a regular basis!
I had the absolute pleasure of dining at Lucy's, and it was hands down the best pizza I've had in a long time! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and light and chewy on the inside. Every topping was fresh and flavorful, and the balance of sauce to cheese was just right. The service was quick and friendly, and the cozy atmosphere just added to the experience. If you’re a pizza lover, this place is a must-try. I’ll definitely be back!
I can start with my own mistake, I ordered online from the wrong location. Note, Idaho Falls is not near Twin Falls, ID! When I arrive at the Lucy’s in Twin Falls I checked on my order only to find out I had ordered from one of the Idaho Falls locations. The crew at the Twin Falls location told me not to worry, they would call the Idaho Falls location and cancel my order and promptly started my order at their location. The pizza was ready about as fast as you could expect, AND, they wouldn’t charge me for my mistake. This Twin Falls location is located in the Second South Market with a very nice bar conveniently located across the way while you wait!!! Friendly attentive staff, and great pizza! Highly recommend! I ordered the 18” 1/2&1/2 1/2 Meaty, 1/2 Zestpian.